Unit 3: Health and Welfare - Grammar 2: must, can’t, may (deduction)

Unit 3: Health and Welfare
Lesson focus: Grammar 2 – must, can’t, may (deduction)

1. Use

mustSure it is true: strong evidence.   He is coughing. He must be ill.
can’tSure it is not true.   He is playing football. He can’t be ill.
may / might / couldNot sure: possible.   He may be at the doctor’s.

2. Form

Presentmodal + infinitive (no to, no -s)   She must be tired. / She must have a cold.
Continuousmodal + be + verb-ing   They must be sleeping.
RememberOpposite of must = can’t (not mustn’t)

3. How sure?

mustmay / might / couldcan’t
100% sure it is trueabout 50% – not sure100% sure it is not true
Teacher’s lesson plan · 55 minutes
First Baccalaureate · Unit 3: Health and Welfare · Grammar 2 – deduction with must, can’t, may / might / could
Main aim: By the end of the lesson, learners will be better able to make deductions about the present using must, can’t and may / might / could, choosing the modal according to how strong the evidence is.
Subsidiary aim: By the end of the lesson, learners will have practised the weak form of must /məs/ and the long vowel in can’t /kɑːnt/, and justified deductions with because in the context of health.
Materials: Presentation; textbook p.47 (Ticket to English 1, only if available); copybook summary.
Timetable fit: Follows Grammar 1 (present perfect); Unit 3 continues.

Key: What you say What to click on screen Textbook Plain text = what students do expected answer

4 min · 0–4T–Ss → S–SLead-inArouse curiosity: Ss make guesses from clues.
Open the lesson; stage 1 is on screen. Press full screen ⛶.“Something is hidden. What is it?”Press Clue 1, then Clue 2.Ss guess in pairs after each clue; T takes ideas and recasts in deduction language without explaining. Press Answer 1; repeat with Mystery 2 (Clues 3–4, Answer 2).Press Today’s goal.
5 min · 4–9T–Ss → S–SContext: cluesShow the target language in a clear context.
Press › to stage 2. Four clues about Hamza are on screen.“Hamza is not at school. Where is he? Why?”Ss discuss in pairs. T collects ideas. Press Detective’s sentences; Ss repeat.
6 min · 9–15T–Ss → S–SGuided discoverySs notice that must / can’t / may show how sure we are.
Press › to stage 3.“How sure is the speaker in each sentence?” Ss discuss in pairs. Press each sentence to show the answer.“Which one is sure it is true? Which one is sure it is not true? Which one is not sure?”Press The rule: the certainty scale appears.
4 min · 15–19S–S → T–SsCheck the meaningCheck understanding (CCQs), one question at a time.
Press › to stage 4.“Read it. Choose with your partner.” Press the answer; Ss see the explanation. Press Next.
5 min · 19–24T–SsForm and pronunciationClarify form; drill weak must and can’t.
Press › to stage 5, then The three patterns.Elicit the form: “What comes after must? With or without to?” → Without to Page 47: compare with the rule box (only if they have the book).Drill chorally then individually, as on the screen.
4 min · 24–28S–S → T–SsControlled practice 1Practise choosing the best modal for the evidence.
Press › to stage 6.“Read the situation. Which is the best deduction?”Drag each one, or tap a situation and then a group.
7 min · 28–35S → T–SsControlled practice 2Practise form and meaning in the unit’s health context.
Page 47, textbook exercise: Ss complete it alone, then compare in pairs. Use stage 7 if they do not have the book.Press › to stage 7.“Eight sentences. Choose the best deduction. Three minutes.”Ss work alone. Correct with Play · Boys vs Girls.
8 min · 35–43S–S → T–SsFreer practiceUse the target language in a personalised information-gap speaking task.
Press › to stage 8.T and a strong S read the model. “A reads. B makes a deduction. Then ask: why do you think so?” ICQ: “Do you say because?” → YesStudent A only / Student B only shows one card.Ss work in pairs; T monitors and notes errors. 3–4 Ss report. Press Example report.
4 min · 43–47S–S → T–SsDelayed error correctionCorrect common errors.
Press › to stage 9.“Each sentence has one mistake. Correct it with your partner.”Press Show all answers.
8 min · 47–55teamsFinal reviewReview form, use and vocabulary; decide the winner.
Press › to stage 10, then ▶ Start the final review. If there is a draw, press Tie-break.

Language analysis

Marker sentenceMeaning & CCQsFormPronunciation
He must be ill.Is the speaker sure? Yes Is there evidence? Yes, he is coughing Is it true or not true? True (probably)must + infinitive (no to, no -s)/hi məs bi ɪl/ – weak must
He can’t be on holiday.Is the speaker sure? Yes True or not true? Not true Is can’t the opposite of must? Yes, for deductioncan't + infinitive/kɑːnt/
He may be at the doctor’s.Is the speaker sure? No Is it possible? Yes Is the evidence strong? Nomay / might / could + infinitive/meɪ/
They must be sleeping.Are they sleeping now? Probably, yesmodal + be + verb-ingweak must
She can’t have a temperature.Is the speaker sure? Yes – she is not illcan't + have + noun/kɑːnt hæv/

Homework: Write six deductions about people at your school or in your family: two with must, two with can’t and two with may / might. Give a reason for each.

Comments